Peekd

Olympic Gymnast Warns of Hidden Cost of Excellence

· news

The Hidden Cost of Excellence: When Athletic Pursuit Trumps Women’s Health

The pursuit of Olympic glory has long been a siren song for athletes, promising fame, fortune, and the thrill of competition at the highest level. For Alexandra Kiroi-Bogatyreva, this drive came at a steep price. As a rhythmic gymnast who competed in the 2024 Paris Olympics and medalled at the Commonwealth Games, she suffered years of malnutrition, overtraining, and menstrual dysfunction.

Kiroi-Bogatyreva’s experience is not unique. Many female athletes have reported similar struggles with their menstrual cycles, often being told that irregular periods are a badge of honor – “you’re really fit if you don’t have your period” is a chilling phrase that echoes through the stories of many athletes. However, this normalization of menstrual irregularities ignores a fundamental aspect of female physiology: menstruation is not just a nuisance to be suppressed or masked; it’s a vital sign of reproductive health.

When athletes neglect their menstrual cycles, they put themselves at risk for long-term health problems – from osteoporosis to fertility issues. The use of birth control pills can mask these issues, but also perpetuates the problem by ignoring underlying causes such as Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S). This condition occurs when the body uses up more calories than it takes in, increasing the risk of injury, illness, and long-term health problems.

The culture of athletic sacrifice is driven by a combination of factors. The sports world has always been obsessed with thinness, speed, and agility – qualities that are often tied to traditional notions of femininity. Athletes like Kiroi-Bogatyreva are caught in a double bind: they’re expected to embody these ideals while also being women.

To address this issue, we need more education and awareness about menstrual health, not just for athletes but for coaches, trainers, and medical professionals as well. We must rethink our definition of athleticism – one that values physical prowess alongside emotional intelligence, self-care, and bodily autonomy. This requires a fundamental shift in the way we approach sports, from training regimens to language used to describe athletic achievement.

The normalization of menstrual irregularities is a symptom of a larger problem: our culture’s disdain for female biology. We’ve medicalized menstruation, turning it into a condition to be managed or suppressed rather than a natural process to be respected. This has far-reaching consequences – from the overuse of birth control pills to the neglect of women’s reproductive health.

The long-term health consequences of ignoring menstrual irregularities are real and serious. Athletes who neglect their menstrual cycles risk developing osteoporosis, fertility issues, and other health problems. It’s time to start talking about these risks – and taking action to prevent them.

Athleticism is not just a physical pursuit; it’s also an emotional and psychological one. We need to redefine our notion of athleticism, valuing self-care, bodily autonomy, and emotional intelligence alongside physical prowess. This requires a fundamental shift in the way we approach sports, from training regimens to language used to describe athletic achievement.

As we move forward, it’s clear that more needs to be done to address the issues facing women in sports. Education and awareness programs, policy changes, and a fundamental shift in our cultural attitudes towards female biology are all necessary steps. It’s time to put women’s bodies – and minds – first.

Reader Views

  • AD
    Analyst D. Park · policy analyst

    While Alexandra Kiroi-Bogatyreva's account is disturbingly familiar, it's also worth noting that men can suffer from RED-S and related health issues due to extreme energy deficits in sports like football or cycling. The article's focus on female athletes may inadvertently perpetuate the myth that women's bodies are uniquely fragile, rather than addressing the broader problem of a culture that prioritizes winning over athlete well-being. A more nuanced discussion would acknowledge the systemic factors driving this imbalance, and consider how sport policies can be adapted to support all athletes, regardless of sex or discipline.

  • CM
    Columnist M. Reid · opinion columnist

    The sports world's fixation on athletic excellence often leads us to overlook the human cost of this pursuit. Alexandra Kiroi-Bogatyreva's harrowing account highlights the pressing need for a shift in culture: one that prioritizes athletes' well-being alongside their performance. But let's not forget that redressing menstrual irregularities and Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S) requires more than just acknowledging the issue – it demands systemic change, including revised coaching methods and more comprehensive support systems. Until we address these underlying causes, female athletes will continue to bear the brunt of a system that values medals over health.

  • RJ
    Reporter J. Avery · staff reporter

    The athlete's body as sacrificial lamb is a deeply ingrained notion in sports culture, but what about the long-term consequences of prioritizing thinness over health? While Alexandra Kiroi-Bogatyreva's bravery in speaking out about her own experiences is laudable, it's essential to consider the systemic factors that perpetuate these issues. One area that deserves more attention is the intersection of RED-S and menstrual irregularities with socioeconomic status. Do athletes from lower-income backgrounds have access to the same support systems and resources as their wealthier counterparts? Until we examine this disparity, we're only scratching the surface of a much larger problem.

Related